Browse All Bayfield CO Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

This wonderful, light and bright home backs to a ton of open space and is just steps from Lake Simpatico. The house is south-facing for tons of sun and natural light. This one won't last with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths and a 2-car garage and well under $500,000. It's in great shape with fantastic views and a fenced backyard. This is a very nice part of Forest Lakes with great access. A nice deck is perfect for relaxing and BBQ's. With dozens of acres of field behind the home it feels very private. Nice garden beds and trees make this a Colorado dream home.There's tons of storage space too. The Seller has had the home pre-inspected and its ready for new owners. Call today to make an appointment to see this home today before it is gone.

1776 Pine Valley Rd, Bayfield

$475,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 839523 MLS

Nestled in the Weminuche Wilderness, 308 Trust Drive is the kind of Colorado retreat that invites you to slow down, breathe a little deeper, and stay awhile. Set on 1.01 peaceful acres, this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath rustic cabin is surrounded by the soothing sounds of the creek, visits from foxes and deer, and the peace, quiet, and solitude that make this setting so special. Inside, approximately 1,000 square feet have been thoughtfully designed with high-quality finishes and a warm, inviting feel. Cozy without compromise, the home is comfortable as either a year-round residence or seasonal mountain escape. Step outside onto the covered porch and find the perfect place for morning coffee, an evening glass of wine, or simply listening to the creek and taking in the stillness of the surrounding landscape. The flat, usable lot offers plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors, while adventure begins just beyond your doorstep. Several hiking trails are within walking distance, National Forest access is nearby, and the waters and recreation of Vallecito Lake are only minutes away. The home remained unaffected by recent high-water events, offering added peace of mind while preserving the beauty and soothing sounds of the seasonal creek. Whether you're searching for a quiet full-time home, a seasonal retreat, or simply a place to reconnect with the outdoors, 308 Trust Drive captures something increasingly hard to find: a peaceful corner of Colorado where the creek runs by, wildlife wanders through, trails are within walking distance, and life feels just a little quieter.

308 Trust Dr, Bayfield

$495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 839477 MLS

Big Lot. Great Location. Endless Potential. This well-located Bayfield property offers the space, setting, and layout buyers are looking for—plus the opportunity to make it truly your own. Situated on a nearly ½ acre lot on a quiet cul-de-sac, this property offers privacy, mature landscaping, great views, and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. The 2,016-square-foot home which was built in 1985 features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a spacious living room, and an oversized great room that adds valuable flexibility for entertaining, recreation, hobbies, or everyday living. The kitchen features solid surface countertops and stainless appliances, while the large rear deck provides an ideal spot to BBQ and take in views of the La Plata Mountains and Pine River Valley. The attached two-car garage offers abundant storage and shelving, plus a hobby room that provides even more usable space. A pellet stove in the great room provides cozy heat in the winter, and the home features an owned solar PV system installed in 2014 tied to the Grid to keep electrical bills in check. Outside, the generous backyard is ready to enjoy with mature trees, plenty of room for a garden area, established landscaping, and room to play, relax, or create your own backyard oasis. Location is hard to beat. A short distance from Bayfield Middle School and conveniently close to the other schools, downtown, shopping, dining, and community amenities, this property puts everyday conveniences within easy reach. With its large private lot, flexible floor plan, established landscaping, views, excellent location, and room to add your own vision, 779 Elm Circle presents a unique opportunity in Bayfield. Come see the possibilities!

779 E Elm Cir, Bayfield

$450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 839346 MLS

Move right in and enjoy easy living near the entrance of Forest Lakes. This well-maintained home has a bright, open main living area with generous windows, and a brand-new Trex deck just off the living room. The kitchen and dining area flow together, while a second living room or den with a wood stove offers a cozy place to unwind. With a primary bedroom on the main floor and a second downstairs, the layout offers flexibility for guests or everyday living. There’s plenty of storage throughout, plus a spacious outdoor shed. Outside, the yard has garden boxes ready for your next planting season, easy parking, and potential space for a garage. From the home, enjoy walkable access to Lake Simpatico, the community park, neighborhood trails and National Forest access within the neighborhood. Bayfield, Vallecito Lake, Lemon Reservoir, and Durango are all within reach. Come see this easy living home in Forest Lakes, ready for it's next owner!

302 Forest Lakes Dr, Bayfield

$450,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 838999 MLS

Tucked away in the beautiful Pine River Valley just minutes from Vallecito Lake, this one-of-a-kind mountain retreat offers the perfect combination of privacy, character, and outdoor living. Originally built in 1916 as the teacherage for the historic Columbus School and thoughtfully expanded and renovated, the home now features approximately 1,850 square feet with 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a dedicated office, and a versatile hobby room. The fully fenced property is designed for enjoying Colorado's mountain lifestyle. Entertain family and friends under the large pavilion, relax in the private hot tub, gather around the firepit, shoot hoops on the basketball court, or simply enjoy the peaceful surroundings and mountain views. Mature landscaping includes lilacs, flowering plants, peach and apple trees, raspberry bushes, chokecherry plants, and 1 acre-foot of Pine River irrigation water rights. Additional features include a one-car garage, dog kennel, multiple outbuildings, and ample space for hobbies, gardening, pets, or outdoor recreation. Located in an area that allows short-term rentals, the property offers flexibility as a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or potential vacation rental opportunity. Buyers should verify all short-term rental requirements with the appropriate governing authorities. Just minutes from Vallecito Lake, you'll enjoy easy access to boating, fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking, hiking, camping, and mountain biking. Conveniently located between Durango and Bayfield, with access to Purgatory Resort, Wolf Creek Ski Area, and Mesa Verde National Park, this property is ideally positioned for year-round adventure. Whether you're seeking a peaceful mountain home, a weekend escape, or a property with income-producing potential, this distinctive retreat offers a lifestyle that's increasingly difficult to find in Southwest Colorado.

7978 County Road 501, Bayfield

$499,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 838792 MLS

SIGNIFICANT PRICE REDUCTION! Located in the heart of downtown Bayfield, just a few blocks from Mill Street, this beautifully remodeled home offers convenient access to local restaurants, shops, and the neighborhood brewery. Originally built in 1900, the home has been lovingly updated—what was old is new again—while much of its rich history and original character has been thoughtfully preserved and enhanced. Enter into the living room with hardwood floors that have been recently refinished and add warmth and beauty throughout. The kitchen is nearing a complete remodel with all new cabinetry, countertops, and appliances. A secondary living area features vaulted ceilings, exposed post-and-beam construction, and a wall of windows that fills the space with natural light. The main level also includes a full bathroom with a classic clawfoot tub and a utility room conveniently located off the kitchen. Upstairs, you’ll find two bedrooms, a versatile loft that could serve as a third bedroom (Assessor lists as a 3 BD), and a three-quarter bathroom showcasing custom tile work and a multi-head shower. A secondary access to the bathroom could easily be added for guest use. The primary bedroom opens to a private deck, creating a peaceful place to enjoy the outdoors. Radiant heat in utility room and living room with tile floors plus a tankless water heater. The landscaped yard features a lush lawn, established gardens, mature trees, and both sprinkler and drip irrigation systems. A large garden shed provides additional storage for tools, equipment, and outdoor gear. With its inviting character, thoughtful updates, and prime downtown location, this distinctive Bayfield home offers comfort, convenience, and small-town charm. call for your private showing today!

420 S Church St, Bayfield

$410,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 838302 MLS

Welcome to your private slice of Colorado just minutes outside Bayfield! Set on three green acres surrounded by views of the tall pines, this nicely maintained home offers space, privacy, and easy access to outdoor recreation. Inside, the bright and spacious open floor plan is filled with natural light and peaceful views from nearly every window. The oversized kitchen features abundant cabinet and counter space, newer stainless steel appliances, a center island, wood-look laminate flooring, and plenty of storage. The inviting living room is warmed by a brand-new pellet stove, while an additional family room with a gas stove provides even more comfortable gathering space. The generous primary suite includes double closets and a private bath with a soaking tub and double sinks. Outside, enjoy the small spring-fed pond supplied by Bear Creek. A detached two-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles, recreational gear, tools, and all your Colorado “toys.” With three acres, this property offers wonderful possibilities for horses, gardening, and recreation. Located close to National Forest and convenient to County Road 501, you can enjoy easy access to Bayfield and nearby amenities while still coming home to a peaceful, private setting.

720 Bear Creek Cir, Bayfield

$475,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 837450 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully remodeled mountain retreat in the highly desirable Forest Lakes community. Set on a peaceful one-acre lot surrounded by towering Ponderosa pines, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers over 1,400 square feet of thoughtfully updated living space in a truly picturesque setting. Improvements include a new roof, fresh interior and exterior paint, and durable metal siding, giving the home both modern appeal and lasting value. Inside, you'll find warm laminate wood flooring, a spacious kitchen with a center island, and a generous dining area featuring a dramatic floor-to-ceiling window that fills the home with natural light and showcases the beautiful forest views. The inviting living room boasts vaulted ceilings, creating an open and airy atmosphere perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The private primary suite offers a walk-in closet and an en-suite bath complete with dual vanities, a soaking garden tub, and a separate shower. Forest Lakes is known for its exceptional outdoor lifestyle. Residents enjoy access to a private lake ideal for fishing, kayaking, and paddle boarding, along with direct access to National Forest and BLM land offering endless opportunities for hiking, mountain biking, wildlife viewing, and hunting. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or a peaceful mountain getaway, this move-in-ready home combines modern updates, natural beauty, and an unbeatable location. Don't miss the opportunity to make this Forest Lakes gem your own!

448 Deer Ridge Dr, Bayfield

$449,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 837199 MLS

Located on a beautifully wooded lot in Forest Lakes, this home is just 15 minutes to Bayfield, and just a few minutes from Lake Simpatico, which is a private lake for this subdivision. Sitting on 1 acre, the home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a bonus room, a pellet stove, an oversized 2 car garage, and a southern facing driveway, which is a benefit during the winter months. The home has an open concept and a nice separation of space between the primary and remaining bedrooms. The front porch boasts views of the rolling hills in the distance, while the back porch allows for privacy and seclusion, as the lot expands past the fence line. At the end of the road, there is a 160 acre open area owned by Forest Lakes, which has emergency fire access. There is also a fire hydrant located across the road, which has helped keep insurance costs down. Ask to see the virtual tour or schedule your private showing today!

133 Pine Cone Dr, Bayfield

$499,000

836698 MLS

This property provides a view that is one of the best scenic views in Colorado. It overlooks Pine Valley and you can see all the way to the La Plata Mountain Range. It provides a paradise for all seasons. Beautiful 35 Acre piine filled acreage in exclusive Beaver Creek Ranch. Private gated entrance provides privacy and protection. Tall Ponderosa pines fill this property making it a sanctuary for elk, deer and turkey. Underground power, and water system to property line make this the premier spot to build your dream home.

Tbd Beaver Creek Ranch, Bayfield

$459,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 834387 MLS

This beautifully redesigned and thoughtfully updated home near Vallecito Reservoir offers modern comforts wrapped in mountain charm. Extensive remodel upgrades include all-new electrical and plumbing, new windows, new blown-in insulation, and new durable vinyl plank flooring. The entryway is washed in morning light and creates a perfect sitting area, while the stylish kitchen features leathered granite counters with a rough edge, custom iron door cabinet pulls, a Haier Euro fridge, and an electric range oven, blending modern function with rustic character. LED lighting illuminates every room, and the abundant natural lighting creates a cozy atmosphere for year-round enjoyment. The 3/4 bath is beautifully finished with a marble vanity and custom tile work in the spacious walk-in shower. One bedroom provides a full closet and a second room functions as a flexible office or guest space with a daybed. Practical updates include a laundry/mudroom with utility sink, new electric baseboard heating in every room, a new electric water heater, and all-electric systems throughout for low-maintenance comfort. The home also features a tiled corner nook for a future free-standing wood-burning fireplace, if desired. Outside, the property impresses with a new front deck, and a stuccoed, insulated and sheet-rocked 1-car garage with decorative wainscoting. The landscaping includes apple trees, lilacs, aspens, iris, and perennial flowers, offering a private, picturesque setting with abundant local wildlife. The home’s exterior features durable stucco with metal wainscoting and a brand-new metal roof, while a spring-fed community well serves these homes with a future cistern in progress to help ensure reliable water access. Part of the beautiful Vallecito Lake community, this property offers a lifestyle rich in recreation. The reservoir stretches for miles and provides excellent opportunities for fishing, boating, paddle boarding, cross country ski trails and abundant opportunities to snow shoe. Bordering the Weminuche region of the San Juan National Forest, the area is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. The home is conveniently close to the marina and just a short drive from the 19.5-mile Vallecito Trail, which leads directly into the 499,771-acre Weminuche Wilderness—the largest wilderness area in Colorado. With every detail thoughtfully updated and modern systems already in place, this home is move-in ready, making it an ideal year-round residence, a mountain getaway, or a turnkey investment property near the lake. Note: The additional vacant parcel in the rear could also be offered for sale, offering additional privacy.

221 Vallecito Dr, Bayfield

$495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 833744 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated single-level home in the Forest Lakes subdivision, set on just over an acre surrounded by towering pines. Built in 2003 and thoughtfully remodeled in 2023, this three-bedroom, two-bath residence blends modern upgrades with the warmth and character of mountain living. The open-concept floor plan is filled with natural light and features maple cabinetry, new durable vinyl flooring throughout, and a spacious kitchen with new stainless steel appliances, ample counter space, and a breakfast bar that flows seamlessly into the dining and living areas. A cozy fireplace and dual-zone radiant in-floor heating provide year-round comfort, while a whole-house fan offers efficient cooling during warmer months. The primary suite and guest bedrooms are bright and inviting, and a separate laundry room adds everyday convenience. Recent improvements include a tankless water heater, whole-house water softener, washer and dryer, fresh interior paint, and a newer asphalt shingle roof. The boiler was replaced in 2020. Outdoor living is equally appealing, with a back deck set against natural rock outcroppings and a covered front porch perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The fully fenced backyard is ideal for pets, and the property has been fully fire mitigated 100 feet from the home, offering added peace of mind. An oversized two-car garage provides ample space for vehicles, storage, and gear. Located near a trailhead with direct access to the San Juan National Forest, this home offers endless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Forest Lakes residents also enjoy year-round road maintenance and a private community lake for paddleboarding, kayaking, and fishing.

1175 Pine Tree Dr, Bayfield

$485,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 833437 MLS

Price Improvement! Now listed at $201 per square foot! Surrounded by towering pines in the Forest Lakes community, this spacious home offers privacy, flexibility, and the peaceful Colorado lifestyle buyers are looking for—just minutes from Bayfield and an easy drive to Durango. With 2,484 square feet of living space, the home features multiple living areas, a flexible floorplan, and room to spread out. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or space for guests and hobbies this easy, turnkey home is the one for you! A new roof provides added peace of mind. Enjoy mornings on the deck, nearby recreation opportunities, and access to the amenities Forest Lakes is known for, including Lake Simpatico access and open space. A garage and abundant storage make it easy to accommodate all your Colorado gear and seasonal needs. If you’ve been searching for mountain living at an approachable price point and close to amenities and outdoor recreation, 607 Forest Lakes Drive deserves a closer look.

607 Forest Lakes Dr, Bayfield

$450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 830739 MLS

Welcome to 758 E Cedar Drive, a well-appointed residence offering comfort, space, and a highly convenient Bayfield location. This 1,600 square-foot home features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a functional open-concept layout designed for everyday living and easy entertaining. Abundant natural light fills the main living areas, creating a bright, welcoming atmosphere throughout the home. Set on a generous half-acre lot, the property is enhanced by mature landscaping that provides privacy, established shade, and a sense of tranquility rarely found so close to town. The two-car garage adds practical storage and parking, while the thoughtfully arranged interior offers a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces. Ideally located just minutes from Bayfield High School and the central business district, this home offers quick access to schools, shopping, dining, and local amenities while still enjoying the benefits of a spacious residential setting. Whether relaxing indoors or enjoying the outdoor space, this property combines functionality, location, and livability in one appealing package.

758 E Cedar, Bayfield

$475,000

822502 MLS

Gorgeous wooded property along Beaver Creek. Almost 20 acres of pristine wooded acreage along a year-around creek. Great privacy and many options for where to build. The homes in the neighborhood are very nice. Great access off Highway 160 and less than 10 minutes to the stores in Bayfield. This property straddles the La Plata and Archuleta County Line with 7.8 acres in La Plata and 12 acres in Archuleta. Electric is nearby. There are allegedly good water wells adjacent to the property. Super sweet property for your Colorado dream home or to buy and hold. Get your slice of Colorado heaven today.

31861 E Hwy 160, Bayfield

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2026. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to limited license rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited. FULL CREN Disclaimer Real Estate listings held by companies other than CREN contain that company's name. Fair Housing Disclaimer This data was last updated:

Between $400K - $500K Bayfield Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Bayfield and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Browse All Bayfield CO Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Between $400K - $500K Bayfield Real Estate

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?