Bayfield CO Historical Real Estate, Homes for Sale - Your Durango Real Estate

Set on 38.79 irrigated acres just outside Bayfield, this versatile rural property combines comfortable residential living with the infrastructure needed for horses, cattle, hay production, and ranch use. The 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 2,558 square feet, a finished basement, mountain views, a covered back deck, fenced yard areas, and multiple outbuildings for livestock, hay, and equipment. The property is set up for a cow operation with pipe corrals, livestock fencing, corral panels used as permanent fencing, and a squeeze chute. Irrigation includes 28.79 sprinkler-irrigated acres and 10 flood-irrigated acres through Pine River Irrigation District, Schroder Irrigating Ditch Co., and the Campbell Lateral. Existing irrigation equipment is included, including the side roll, a recently installed 10 HP motor and pump, new foot valve and intake pipe, hoses, pipes, and sprinklers. A portable above-ground yard-watering setup connects to the irrigation system and allows most of the yard to be watered at once. Recent improvements include new appliances, a propane cookstove, propane tankless water heater, new range hood, extensive new plumbing, a Liberty NexGen Hybrid wood stove with reconstructed flue components, a new domestic-well pressure tank, a 30-amp RV hookup, updated electrical work in the garage and pump house, new garage-door operating components, new storm doors and rear French doors, Kwikset SmartKey locks, replacement window screens, bathroom updates, and fencing improvements. Domestic water is supplied by a permitted well, and sewer service is provided by a septic system. Internet service is available at the residence, and the buyer will need to arrange service with their chosen provider. The property is also subject to a recorded conservation easement. Buyers should review the conservation-easement documents and verify all permitted uses, restrictions, water rights, irrigation information, and transfer requirements during due diligence. With productive irrigated acreage, livestock infrastructure, substantial storage, and easy access to Bayfield, this property offers a strong combination of rural functionality and Southwest Colorado living.

7351 County Road 523, Bayfield

$350,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 836966 MLS

Situated on just over an acre with no covenants, this inviting country property just minutes from downtown Bayfield, schools, shops, and more offers room to spread out and enjoy the freedom of rural living. Inside, the floor plan creates comfortable, functional living spaces. The kitchen is filled with natural light and features a propane gas range, refrigerator, distinctive steel countertops, and an adjoining laundry/mudroom that provides convenient access to the oversized one-car garage with high ceilings and abundant storage. The welcoming living room is anchored by a cozy wood-burning stove and oversized windows that fill the home with natural light. One of the three bedrooms is located just off the living area and features a generous closet and direct access to the backyard, making it equally well-suited as a home office, guest room, or flex space. Two additional bedrooms are tucked down the hall, including a spacious primary bedroom with dual closets and French doors opening to the backyard - perfect for enjoying peaceful mornings or evening sunsets. The centrally located full bathroom has been tastefully updated with a tiled tub surround, modern fixtures, and a single-sink vanity. Outside, the property offers endless possibilities. The backyard extends beyond the barn, creating ample space for gardening, animals, hobbies, recreation, or future improvements. With over an acre of land, no HOA, and a comfortable home ready to enjoy, this property is an exceptional opportunity to experience the flexibility and lifestyle that country living provides. NOTE: The property is being sold "AS IS" and will require a new septic system at Buyer's expense.

1712 County Road 501, Bayfield

$3,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 836832 MLS

Some of the best water in La Plata County runs across this ground. Ask any rancher around here what that's worth. You get real acreage with a home, greenhouses built at scale, tiny homes, a pond, and irrigation that shows up when the ditch calls. The soil's fertile. It's been hayed and cattle-leased for years, which keeps it in Ag status and the taxes historically low. Valley and mountains in nearly every direction. The greenhouses are ready to run as-is or convert to whatever you've got in mind. The caretaker home is rustic and full of character, or think of it as the footing for the forever home you build looking out over that valley. Run cattle. Grow something. Start a business on it. There's room for all three. This parcel is part of a larger ranch sale, so if you're after bigger acreage, take a look at the other MLS listings tied to it. Then there's Bayfield. Pine River fly water, Wolverine football on Friday nights, Saturday morning farmers market on Mill Street, Vallecito Reservoir a short drive up the valley. You're less than 10 minutes from the school and downtown, with regional air service through the Durango-La Plata County Airport.

5759 County Road 501, Bayfield

$650,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 834474 MLS

Your slice of paradise has been found! If you want a serene and quiet setting, then this beautiful home is for you. This wonderful property is in a gated community and is on 0.331 acres. It sits on the bank of D creek which runs all year. The property has its own pond and a majestic and calming waterfall. Enjoy nature all around, as you sit on the large deck and relax or have a great backyard BBQ with family and friends! This home has had remodeling done which is evident as soon as you walk in. You are greeted into a large great room/living area with vaulted ceilings and a custom-made fireplace for those cold winter nights. New hardwood flooring and custom paneling throughout. The kitchen, is equipped with granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances a great walk-in pantry and a bay window. Also on the main level is the main bath along with a non-conforming bonus room that can be used as a den/office or guest overflow sleeping area. The second level has a very nice sitting/office area looking over the great room. Also located on this floor is the spacious ensuite, with a large walk in closet and access to the back deck looking over D creek. Sit and enjoy an evening on this private deck. The bath has a custom tiled walk-in shower. Rounding out this second level is a guest bedroom and bath. Enjoy Vallecito Lake, hiking, fishing and all the beautiful valley has to offer. Great local restaurants and a general store. It is a short drive to Durango and Bayfield, Colorado. You will not be disappointed in this beautiful and unique property. Call and set up your private showing today. This home is move in ready and waiting for you!

1429 County Road 500, Bayfield

$459,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 834387 MLS

This beautifully redesigned and thoughtfully updated home near Vallecito Reservoir offers modern comforts wrapped in mountain charm. Extensive remodel upgrades include all-new electrical and plumbing, new windows, new blown-in insulation, and new durable vinyl plank flooring. The entryway is washed in morning light and creates a perfect sitting area, while the stylish kitchen features leathered granite counters with a rough edge, custom iron door cabinet pulls, a Haier Euro fridge, and an electric range oven, blending modern function with rustic character. LED lighting illuminates every room, and the abundant natural lighting creates a cozy atmosphere for year-round enjoyment. The 3/4 bath is beautifully finished with a marble vanity and custom tile work in the spacious walk-in shower. One bedroom provides a full closet and a second room functions as a flexible office or guest space with a daybed. Practical updates include a laundry/mudroom with utility sink, new electric baseboard heating in every room, a new electric water heater, and all-electric systems throughout for low-maintenance comfort. The home also features a tiled corner nook for a future free-standing wood-burning fireplace, if desired. Outside, the property impresses with a new front deck, and a stuccoed, insulated and sheet-rocked 1-car garage with decorative wainscoting. The landscaping includes apple trees, lilacs, aspens, iris, and perennial flowers, offering a private, picturesque setting with abundant local wildlife. The home’s exterior features durable stucco with metal wainscoting and a brand-new metal roof, while a spring-fed community well serves these homes with a future cistern in progress to help ensure reliable water access. Part of the beautiful Vallecito Lake community, this property offers a lifestyle rich in recreation. The reservoir stretches for miles and provides excellent opportunities for fishing, boating, paddle boarding, cross country ski trails and abundant opportunities to snow shoe. Bordering the Weminuche region of the San Juan National Forest, the area is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. The home is conveniently close to the marina and just a short drive from the 19.5-mile Vallecito Trail, which leads directly into the 499,771-acre Weminuche Wilderness—the largest wilderness area in Colorado. With every detail thoughtfully updated and modern systems already in place, this home is move-in ready, making it an ideal year-round residence, a mountain getaway, or a turnkey investment property near the lake. Note: The additional vacant parcel in the rear could also be offered for sale, offering additional privacy.

221 Vallecito Dr, Bayfield

$260,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 833912 MLS

Charming 1911 bungalow in the heart of downtown Bayfield, CO—an ideal blend of historic character and everyday convenience. This well-loved home features classic period details, a welcoming front porch, and a cozy layout perfect for comfortable living or rental income. Located within easy walking distance to Bayfield’s restaurants, shops, and parks, enjoy a vibrant small-town lifestyle with community events and outdoor recreation just steps away. An inspection report is on file for buyer review, making this an excellent option for first-time homeowners or investors seeking a turnkey opportunity. There is a brand new refridgerator and range/oven making this kitchen ready for its new owners. Commuters and weekend explorers will appreciate being only 20 minutes from downtown Durango, offering added convenience and regional amenities.

589 East St, Bayfield

$485,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 833629 MLS

Tucked away in the beautiful Pine River Valley just minutes from Vallecito Lake, this one-of-a-kind mountain retreat offers the perfect combination of privacy, character, and outdoor living. Originally built in 1916 as the teacherage for the historic Columbus School and thoughtfully expanded and renovated, the home now features approximately 1,850 square feet with 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a dedicated office, and a versatile hobby room. The fully fenced property is designed for enjoying Colorado's mountain lifestyle. Entertain family and friends under the large pavilion, relax in the private hot tub, gather around the firepit, shoot hoops on the basketball court, or simply enjoy the peaceful surroundings and mountain views. Mature landscaping includes lilacs, flowering plants, peach and apple trees, raspberry bushes, chokecherry plants, and 1 acre-foot of Pine River irrigation water rights. Additional features include a one-car garage, dog kennel, multiple outbuildings, and ample space for hobbies, gardening, pets, or outdoor recreation. Located in an area that allows short-term rentals, the property offers flexibility as a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or potential vacation rental opportunity. Buyers should verify all short-term rental requirements with the appropriate governing authorities. Just minutes from Vallecito Lake, you'll enjoy easy access to boating, fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking, hiking, camping, and mountain biking. Conveniently located between Durango and Bayfield, with access to Purgatory Resort, Wolf Creek Ski Area, and Mesa Verde National Park, this property is ideally positioned for year-round adventure. Whether you're seeking a peaceful mountain home, a weekend escape, or a property with income-producing potential, this distinctive retreat offers a lifestyle that's increasingly difficult to find in Southwest Colorado.

7978 County Road 501, Bayfield

$1,650,000

14 Beds ⋅ 9 Baths ⋅ 833303 MLS

Eagle’s Nest Cabins is a rare and versatile mountain retreat located just north of Vallecito Reservoir, approximately 30 minutes from Durango and 20 minutes from Bayfield. This exceptional property includes a main lodge, three income-producing log cabins, and a caretaker’s studio cottage, all situated on just over three acres with an additional 0.80-acre vacant lot included in the sale. The property offers access to the National Forest just minutes away and provides endless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Together, the improvements total 5,449 square feet of living space and are ideally suited for use as a vacation rental business, bed-and-breakfast, wedding venue, corporate retreat, or private family compound. Current rental projections exceed $120,000 annually. The 2,137-square-foot main lodge, built in 1961, features four bedrooms and two baths with generous living areas, making it ideal for owner occupancy or guest accommodations. The three log cabins, each built in 1969, offer 1,024 square feet with three bedrooms, two baths, full kitchens, and wood-burning fireplaces. A caretaker’s cottage above the garage provides additional flexibility for management or guest space. The 0.80-acre vacant lot offers potential for RV parking, storage, or additional rental pads. Three private fishing ponds add to the charm of the setting, which is surrounded by mountain beauty and abundant wildlife. Year-round activities such as hiking, boating, fishing, paddleboarding, and snowshoeing are easily accessible, and the property’s convenient location places it within a short drive of both Bayfield and Durango. Eagle’s Nest Cabins presents a unique opportunity to own a turnkey income property or private mountain getaway in one of Southwest Colorado’s most scenic destinations.

48 W Vallecito Creek Rd, Bayfield

$800,000

9 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 833295 MLS

Positioned just north of Vallecito Reservoir, Eagles Nest Cabins present a rare opportunity to acquire a turnkey mountain retreat with built-in income potential. Set on 1.78 acres and bordering nearby National Forest access, the property includes three well-maintained cabins totaling approximately 3,200 square feet. Two cabins offer 1,024 square feet each, with a third at 1,152 square feet. All three feature three bedrooms, two full baths, full kitchens, and wood-burning fireplaces, creating comfortable, functional accommodations suited for year-round enjoyment. The setting is quiet and private, with an on-site fishing pond, mature trees, and easy access to Vallecito's recreational amenities. This property is well-positioned for multiple uses, including short-term vacation rentals, long-term income production, or a commercial hospitality operation. Projected nightly rental income ranges from approximately $22,000 to $26,000 per cabin annually, offering strong potential returns. Additional improvements include a shared laundry facility and ample space for guest parking and outdoor enjoyment. Whether utilized as an income-producing asset, a family compound, or a company retreat, Eagles Nest Cabins provide flexibility, location, and immediate usability in one of Southwest Colorado’s most desirable recreational corridors.

18 Vallecito Creek Rd, Bayfield

$800,000

833294 MLS

Positioned just north of Vallecito Reservoir, Eagles Nest Cabins present a rare opportunity to acquire a turnkey mountain retreat with built-in income potential. Set on 1.78 acres and bordering nearby National Forest access, the property includes three well-maintained cabins totaling approximately 3,200 square feet. Two cabins offer 1,024 square feet each, with a third at 1,152 square feet. All three feature three bedrooms, two full baths, full kitchens, and wood-burning fireplaces, creating comfortable, functional accommodations suited for year-round enjoyment. The setting is quiet and private, with an on-site fishing pond, mature trees, and easy access to Vallecito's recreational amenities. This property is well-positioned for multiple uses, including short-term vacation rentals, long-term income production, or a commercial hospitality operation. Projected nightly rental income ranges from approximately $22,000 to $26,000 per cabin annually, offering strong potential returns. Additional improvements include a shared laundry facility and ample space for guest parking and outdoor enjoyment. Whether utilized as an income-producing asset, a family compound, or a company retreat, Eagles Nest Cabins provide flexibility, location, and immediate usability in one of Southwest Colorado’s most desirable recreational corridors.

18 Vallecito Creek Rd, Bayfield

$850,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 833289 MLS

Tucked into the peaceful setting just north of Vallecito Reservoir, 48 West Vallecito Creek presents a rare opportunity to own a versatile mountain property with both residential comfort and income potential. Situated on 1.3 acres—with an additional adjacent 0.80-acre parcel included—this offering provides privacy, usable land, and close proximity to National Forest access, making it an ideal base for outdoor recreation and year-round enjoyment. The main residence features approximately 2,249 square feet, including a well-designed four-bedroom, two-bath layout, with the primary living space totaling just over 1,800 square feet. The home offers a functional floor plan with generous living areas, a full kitchen, and the warmth and character expected in a Colorado mountain retreat. Above the detached garage, a 448-square-foot caretaker apartment adds flexibility for guest accommodations, long-term rental income, or on-site property management. Vacation rental projections for the main home are estimated at $33,000 to $39,000 annually, with the studio apartment offering an additional $11,000 to $14,000 in potential income per year. Complementing the natural setting, the property benefits from proximity to fishing, ponds, and abundant wildlife, as well as easy access to surrounding public lands. Whether utilized as a primary residence, vacation retreat, or part of a larger investment strategy alongside the nearby cabin offerings, this property delivers multiple use options, including short-term rental potential, multi-generational living, or a private family compound.

48 W Vallecito Creek Rd, Bayfield

$495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 833107 MLS

Experience a sophisticated to the studs renovation in the heart of Old Town Bayfield. This historic 1,430 sq. ft. home has been masterfully updated with a modern contemporary feel and high-end finishes throughout. The comprehensive remodel included a full electrical service update, all-new wiring, and a transition to Pex and PVC plumbing. The interior features fresh drywall, new lighting, and ceiling fans, complemented by a designer kitchen boasting new cabinetry, countertops, and a stylish backsplash. The floor plan offers three bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, including a reconfigured laundry space with an added toilet and high-end Milgard windows in the living area and bath. Comfort is guaranteed year-round with two new mini-split units for powerful cooling and a new boiler combo installed in late 2025 for primary heat and hot water. All new appliances—including the washer and dryer—are included. The exterior is equally impressive, featuring a durable metal roof, new front and rear fencing, and a cedar-lined front yard. The attached garage has been upgraded with insulated operable doors, LED lighting, and a sealed floor. For those with adventure in mind, the 0.254-acre lot provides dedicated RV parking with no HOA restrictions. Located on a premier walking and biking route, you are steps away from the Pine River, downtown parks, and the vibrant restaurants on Mill Street. Whether you are hitting the Saul’s Creek trails or fishing at nearby Vallecito Lake, this home serves as the ultimate high-end basecamp for the Colorado lifestyle.

14 E South St, Bayfield

$562,500

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 833096 MLS

Escape to this stunning 5.9-acre property featuring a charming 3-bedroom farmhouse. Enjoy tranquil evenings on the porch with breathtaking views of the Pine River Valley and the soothing sounds of the Pine River running through the valley. Ideal for outdoor enthusiasts, with Vallecito Lake and National Forest access just minutes away for fishing, hiking, boating and more. This property has a 3 bd, 1 ba Farmhouse on 5.9 acres with no covenants. Conveniently located 12 minutes from Bayfield and just 5 minutes from Vallecito Lake. In addition to the home, the property has an old storage shed in the back yard, a root cellar, detached 2-car garage and a large AG building for good dry storage.

10643 County Road 501, Bayfield

$470,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 832882 MLS

The Heart of the Mill Street District: If you want to live where the action is without sacrificing your peace and quiet, this is the one. Located in the Historic Mill Street District, you are literally 150 feet from the front door to the best of downtown Bayfield. You can walk to Bottom Shelf Brewery for dinner or stroll down to Joe Stephenson Park for the Fourth of July fireworks. While the location puts you in the center of the action, the home is uniquely positioned to act as a private sanctuary that feels worlds away from the street. High-End Infrastructure & Modern Comfort: This ranch-style home has been structurally refreshed from the top down, offering the kind of stability you rarely find in a historic district. Chef’s Kitchen: Features a vaulted ceiling, a massive 5x8 solid granite slab island, and a dedicated pot filler over the stove. Radiant Heat: Luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout are heated by efficient natural gas in-floor radiant heat. Total Structural Peace of Mind: The roof structure was completely rebuilt from the deck up, the attic has been stabilized, and the crawl space is confirmed dry. The Tech Edge: This home is fiber-ready for Clearnetworx, providing the most reliable high-speed internet available in downtown Bayfield. Versatility & Professional Potential: The home is zoned "Town Center," which opens the door for a variety of home-based business opportunities right in the center of town. The Master Suite: Includes a solid granite vanity and a pocket door that can close off the bedroom wing for extra privacy. Secure Storage: The large two-car garage has been power-washed from top to bottom and is ready for your vehicles and mountain gear. Your Private Outdoor Oasis: The exterior is a low-maintenance retreat designed for social summer evenings. The Garden: A serene, fenced-in sanctuary featuring apricot trees, a mature herb garden, and a flagstone patio. Smart Irrigation: A specialized dual-action system handles the soaking and spraying for the mature trees. Prime Location: You are less than a mile from all Bayfield public schools and within easy reach of Eagle Park’s river access. With the infrastructure rebuilt and the downtown lifestyle at your doorstep, this is a turnkey opportunity to own a piece of Bayfield history.

486 S Church St, Bayfield

$1,000,000

832442 MLS

4 Properties located in the heart of Bayfield, Colorado on historic Mill Street create 1 unique opportunity. These income producing properties: 34 E Mill St, 24 E Mill St, 16 E Mill St have a total of 4242sf and on nearly a 1/2 acre of land. The properties are of mixed use, having both commercial and residential tenants. This area of Bayfield has been undergoing a renewal with a thriving restaurant scene, retail stores and residential units creating a vibrant community. As a whole this property allows for positive cash flow while redevelopment plans are made.

34 E Mill St, Bayfield

$575,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 831950 MLS

Creekfront mountain living near Vallecito Lake with a guest apartment, RV hookups, and year-round access. Nestled among towering pines in the highly desirable Ponderosa subdivision, this charming Colorado mountain cabin sits along the banks of Grimes Creek, offering the soothing sounds of running water, mountain views, privacy, and the ultimate Southwest Colorado lifestyle. Just minutes from Vallecito Lake, the marina, boat ramps, hiking trails, fishing access, and the San Juan National Forest, this property is ideally positioned as a primary residence, vacation home, short-term rental opportunity, or multi-generational mountain retreat. The main home features an open-concept floor plan with vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, a spacious living area, functional kitchen, dining space, two main-level bedrooms, full bath, laundry area, and a versatile upper-level loft, bunk room, office, or guest space with an additional bathroom. A forced-air furnace provides comfortable year-round living. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate direct creek frontage, a private footbridge crossing Grimes Creek, RV parking with hookups, multiple storage sheds, and a detached two-car garage with a separate guest apartment above complete with its own sleeping area and bathroom—perfect for visitors, extended family, a caretaker, studio, home office, or potential rental income. Located approximately 30 minutes from Durango and surrounded by endless recreation including boating, paddleboarding, kayaking, fly fishing, hiking, horseback riding, ATV trails, snowmobiling, hunting, and access to the Weminuche Wilderness, this property offers the rare combination of creekfront living, guest accommodations, mountain charm, and no HOA or restrictive covenants. Properties with Grimes Creek frontage this close to Vallecito Lake rarely become available.

403 Ponderosa Homes Dr, Bayfield

$1,143,820

830952 MLS

This is a rare opportunity to acquire a historic Bayfield property prominently located at the corner of S. East Street and E. South Street. The original structure, constructed in 1930, reflects nearly a century of local history and character. The property is currently tenant-occupied, with established tenants who wish to remain in place and who provide valued services to the greater Bayfield community. In addition to the original building, the site includes two modular structures that contribute additional leasable square footage. The parcel spans approximately 300 by 300 feet, totaling roughly 2.6 acres. The southeastern portion of the property may offer potential for future redevelopment, subject to applicable approvals and zoning considerations.

658 S East St, Bayfield

$2,250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 828935 MLS

Three parcels totaling 454 acres joining the San Juan National Forest. The property provides great hunting opportunities for Elk, Deer, Bear and turkeys as well as exploring the great outdoors. There is an older farm house that has been updated as well as a Hobby Cabin/Guest Cabin.

10875 County Road 501, Bayfield

$925,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 827293 MLS

The Lake House at Vallecito Reservoir | Positioned directly across the road from the marina at Vallecito Reservoir, this property is all about lifestyle, flexibility, and year-round income potential. Known as “The Lake House,” this home includes a separate apartment (ADU) with a private entrance, deck, and its own hot tub—bringing in a steady $3,000 per month. Use it as a turnkey rental or guest quarters, while still enjoying the main house yourself. The primary residence has never been rented but certainly could be, with strong demand in this sought-after area. There’s no HOA or covenants, giving you full freedom with the property. The attached two-car garage offers convenience, while the separate 34’x15’ boat house can handle a boat, RV, side-by-side, or other gear with room to spare. Outdoors, a huge deck overlooks big lake and mountain views, with brilliant fall colors and sunsets that never disappoint. This property also includes a boat and remaining season slip rental at the full-service marina just across the street! Additionally the homes comes turn key. Just bring your toothbrush! Step outside and be on the water recreating or entertaining in minutes. Vallecito is known for excellent fishing—brown and rainbow trout, walleye, northern pike, and smallmouth bass are all in play. At the lake you will love having 2 restaurants, a general store and a liquor store. Just a few minutes up the road, you’ll find trailheads into the San Juan National Forest for hiking, mountain biking, ATVing, and backcountry camping. Located about 30 minutes from downtown Durango and around 40 minutes from La Plata County Airport, the home is close enough for convenience but far enough for peace and quiet. Bayfield is about 20 minutes away and Purgatory Resort is within an hour for skiing and winter recreation. Whether you're looking for a part-time mountain escape with income, or a full-time residence with unmatched access to the lake and mountains, The Lakehouse delivers it—without restrictions or compromise. There is a 4th bedroom used as an office currently, the 5th is the ADU. Both are non conforming. Rental history and financials available upon request. Contact agent directly for a private tour.

14697 County Road 501, Bayfield

$289,900

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 822817 MLS

Great Location in Downtown Bayfield With Off-Street Parking! This one-bedroom one-bath home features brand new flooring in the bedroom, living room, utility room and upstairs, tile flooring throughout the rest of the home, as well as newer window shades. The lot is shaded by beautiful tall trees and it is easy to maintain. There's a shed for storage and your very own fruit tree as well. The famous Bayfield 4th of July Parade goes right by this home and you can watch from the front yard. Despite being downtown, the traffic is light and the location is peaceful. Owned by the same family for two generations and originally a carriage house, you can own a piece of history-this cute as can be home has lots of potential!

1298 Bayfield Pkwy, Bayfield

$490,000

826260 MLS

Exceptional Investment or Redevelopment Opportunity in Downtown Bayfield! An incredible chance for investors, owner-occupants, or developers—this unique offering includes two separate properties sold together, totaling nearly half an acre in the heart of downtown Bayfield with NO HOA. Currently home to the thriving camper builder and dealer San Juan Vans, the business has outgrown the space, opening the door for a new owner to capitalize on the existing infrastructure or pursue future redevelopment. 43 South Street features excellent street frontage, a 1,375 sq ft shop with a two-bay mechanic garage, lift, and 220V power, plus a separate storage area. This parcel also extends across South Street, providing valuable additional parking. 580 S. West Street, which adjoins the South Street parcel, includes a 3,200 sq ft Quonset hut workshop with dedicated office space and a partial loft—perfect for storage or workspace expansion. Both properties are heated by natural gas overhead heaters and offer ample on-site parking and storage, creating a highly flexible setup for a wide range of uses. They are also served by ClearNetworx FiberOptic internet. Contact an agent for more details or to schedule a private tour of this rare downtown Bayfield opportunity.

43 South St, Bayfield

$365,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 824303 MLS

This cozy gem is a verdant oasis in downtown, historic Bayfield; located just blocks from restaurants, retail, a parks, river access and a brewery. Recent updates include a remodeled bathroom downstairs, an additional bathroom upstairs, fresh paint, and updated fixtures. Plenty of storage and natural light is found throughout this lovingly cared for home. The mud/laundry room connects the bright kitchen with oak cabinets, to a patio and the fully fenced in yard, which will satisfy all your green thumb impulses. The current owners put a lot of love and care into the yard; there are multiple raised beds, apple and plum trees, garlic, strawberry and raspberry bushes, perennial flowers blooming throughout the season, along with shade trees to keep things cool during the hot summers, and an in-ground sprinkler system set up to keep things lush and blooming. There is a 15'x11' storage shed wired for electric with additional storage above, perfect for a small shop space, or for starting a garden- which can then be transferred to the attached 12'x6' greenhouse.

380 Pearl St, Bayfield

$280,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 806149 MLS

Welcome to this timeless 1937 home, located on the edge of town outside of Bayfield CO. This charming three bedroom, two bathroom with office, has plenty of personality with original hardwood floors and custom pine built ins throughout. The large basement is perfect for storage or a workshop while the fenced backyard offers plenty of privacy and outdoor living space. This fixer-upper has been updated with new windows and sump pumps, making it ready for you to add your personal touch and update to your desire! With 1.15 acres just outside city limits, this home provides a great balance between country living and city convenience – come see what this classic beauty can offer today!

920 Bayfield Pkwy, Bayfield

$460,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 823213 MLS

Do you like forested surroundings, dark sky nights and wildlife abound? Then this is the home for you. This well-maintained home sits on 1.476 acres in a quiet, peaceful area amongst Ponderosa and Blue Spruce trees. The home is 1,472 square feet with two bedrooms and one full bath on the main floor, and two bedrooms and a second bath on the second floor. Each bedroom has its own large closet space. This home has plenty of room to entertain family and friends while enjoying the serene and secluded surroundings. New double-paned windows, a sliding patio door and kitchen door have been recently installed. The open concept kitchen features an eat at bar with beautiful rock work and antique wagon wheel. The living area has a wood burning rock fireplace which is great for warming up on those chilly winter nights. Enjoy the warmth of the small gas fireplace stove in the quaint sitting area. The large deck is a wonderful place to spend time, with its amazing mountain views, and watch all the wildlife that roam this great property. You will see various species of birds along with chipmunks, squirrels, and deer as well as other wildlife that meander through. The gas fire pit gives off a great ambiance while sitting on the deck in the evening with a clear view of the night sky for star gazing. The property is partially fenced with a privacy fence. Bring your boat, RV, and toys as there is a large RV/camper carport for great storage. Also included is a 20 x 10 Zircon with an attached carport and an additional storage shed located on the property. Vallecito Creek is nearby as well as Vallecito Lake. Vallecito Lake has twelve miles of shoreline and is known for its beauty and fishing for Trout, Kokanee Salmon, and Pike. Enjoy hiking, boating, fishing, or just the quietness of nature. Do not let this amazing property get away! The possibilities are endless. Set up a private showing today! Own a piece of paradise at beautiful Vallecito Lake.

708 Tucker Ln, Bayfield

$349,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 806511 MLS

Charming farmhouse located in Bayfield. This property features a 2,484 SF of living space with ample storage in the detached 3 car. The home which has been remodeled over the years features 3 bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths, a nice sunroom and large den which in the past was used a 4th bedroom (no closet). Outside features mature trees, a great yard, a detached 3 car garage with a finished attic, and a livestock barn for additional storage or your 4H animals.

2107 Bayfield Pkwy, Bayfield

$490,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 812977 MLS

39 irrigated acres with ponds. Partially fenced. Views of the LaPlata Mountains and all the spectacular scenery around. Close to the town of Bayfield. This 3 bedroom 1 bath home is just waiting for a beautiful fix up. The water well has a brand new pump! Possible potential to subdivide - Buyer to verify. ALL MINERAL RIGHTS ARE EXCLUDED.

5137 County Road 516, Bayfield

$410,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 817917 MLS

Nestled on a charming corner lot in downtown Bayfield this historic stucco home exudes character and warmth. The two bedroom one bath home has a lovely remodel and a HUGE bathroom and is complemented by extensive landscaping, creating a serene and inviting outdoor space. A lovely deck offers the perfect spot for relaxing or entertaining, while the property's prime location makes it an easy walk to town. The detached garage adds convenience and extra storage, making this home an ideal blend of historic charm and modern practicality.

440 S Pine St, Bayfield

$425,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 802323 MLS

Offering a $10,000 concession for buyers to use towards closing costs, rate buy down, or applied to purchase price. Experience the ultimate blend of location and charm with this adorable home nestled in the heart of Bayfield! Situated on just under a half-acre of land, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home is steps away from multiple restaurants and a beautiful park, offering the perfect blend of convenience and tranquility. This home boasts brand new carpet and windows. Inside, the beautiful kitchen features newer appliances, abundant natural light, and a delightful view of the backyard, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for culinary enthusiasts and entertainers alike. Step outside into your own private oasis, where raised garden beds, multiple fruit trees, raspberry bushes, and lush green grass beckon you to enjoy the outdoors. The fully fenced chicken coop adds to the charm and potential for a sustainable lifestyle, allowing you to embrace the joys of farm-to-table living. Additional features of this property include a carriage house that offers endless possibilities, whether it be as a garage conversion, workshop, or extra storage. The convenient RV parking spot with an electrical plug off the outbuilding provides added convenience for those with recreational vehicles. This location is truly phenomenal and offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Bayfield's coveted real estate. Don't miss out on this exquisite home that won't last long on the market!

90 Mill St, Bayfield

$255,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 821302 MLS

This downtown Bayfield cottage sits on a generous lot and offers a great opportunity for a buyer looking to make it their own. The home has a simple, functional layout with plenty of potential. The outdoor space provides room to garden, relax, or enjoy the surroundings. Conveniently located in a quiet neighborhood near local amenities, this property is full of possibilities.

43 W North St, Bayfield

$314,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 808923 MLS

Introducing this cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom country home, sitting on a nearly quarter-acre lot with irrigation. It effortlessly combines rustic charm with move in ready comfort. Inside, you'll find two comfortable bedrooms, open kitchen and living room, and a flexible bonus room that could serve as an extra bedroom, home office, or hobby space. Outside, the fenced property includes an irrigation system, fruit trees, large back deck and plenty of space to roam for pets and people alike. No HOA or covenants lends a variety of options for your living situation and storage needs. Recent updates, such as new flooring and fresh interior and exterior paint, give the home a fresh look. Conveniently located between Bayfield and Durango, it offers easy commuting access to both towns. Come see this little gem in Gem Village!

142 County Road 507, Bayfield

$505,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 820608 MLS

83 S Mesa Ave, Bayfield

$334,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 814472 MLS

Charming home only a 1/2 mile west of downtown Bayfield. The home sits on a 1 acre parcel with great views and southern exposure. The home, which was originally constructed in 1942 has been updated over the years and has been well maintained and is ready for a new owner. It has one legal bedroom and a second non-conforming bedroom and a full bathroom. The home is heated by a forced air gas fired furnace and wood burning stove to keep you worm on those cold winter nights. Water is provided by a well and the sewer is provided by the town of Bayfield. There is also a small barn and the property will allow for your 4-H animals. This property would be perfect for the first time buyer or an investor looking for a redevelopment opportunity. Call today to schedule a showing.

660 Bayfield Pkwy, Bayfield

$299,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 805303 MLS

This country home sits on .665 lush acres. It has a large enclosed porch to enjoy summer evenings with outside access to the garage way and entry to the kitchen. The kitchen is large and has an oversized laundry that opens to a mud room to an enclosed entryway on the west side. The home also features a front enclosed entry / mudroom to remove those wet boots before accessing the living room. Make this you home workshop and space to play, garden and have all your toys. Fruit trees are waiting for you to make that prize apple pie. A 25x 14' attached work shop is great for your projects. An additional small shed will house your garden tools. A 10x18' carport type shelter can shelter your side by side or tractor. The ditch runs on the east side providing a bit more h20 for an ample sized garden from the GEM VILLIAGE LAND OWNERS AND WATER USERS ASSOSIATES. At this time fees are 20/year. The home has a historic well. RV friendly. An oversized 1 car garage plus storage accesses the home by a covered open Breezeway and walkway between the home and Garage. located in Gem Village Between Bayfield and Durango makes for an easy trip for supplies and entertainment. Natural forest and an outdoor playground will challenge the adventurous. Priced to sell this home won't last!

39743 Us Hwy 160 Hill, Bayfield

$495,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 826469 MLS

Escape to the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort in this beautifully maintained cabin. Nestled among towering pines and just minutes from Vallecito Lake, this ready retreat is your gateway to serene mountain lake living. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be captivated by the warm wood interiors, and the inviting wood burning fireplace—perfect for cozy evenings after a day on the lake. The well-equipped kitchen features rustic cabinetry, new countertops, and a beautiful copper sink, ideal for both everyday living and entertaining guests. Three bedrooms provide comfort and privacy, while the updated bathrooms offer convenience without losing the cabin’s cozy appeal. Step outside to a serene and usable lot to soak in the sounds of nature. There is a designated fire pit area and space for outdoor entertaining. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or a vacation rental investment, this cabin offers the perfect opportunity to own a piece of mountain paradise.

1490 County Road 500, Bayfield

$455,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 814953 MLS

Welcome to this Cutie By The Creek, a charming, freshly painted property perfect for buyers seeking a mini farm lifestyle with minimal maintenance and upkeep. Easily accessed by paved roads and nestled on nearly an acre that feels and lives much more expansive. Offering incredible privacy, this property features two outbuildings, a fantastic chicken coop, small pond, mature fruit trees, and ideal garden spots. With no HOA or covenants, you have the freedom to embrace homesteading to your heart's content. Centrally located, you are just 5 minutes from the town of Bayfield and 15 minutes from Durango, offering both convenience and tranquility. The interior is equally appealing, boasting updated plumbing and electrical systems, stunning brickwork, and vintage barn wood plank accent walls. Choose between the cozy ambiance of the efficient wood stove or the ease and comfort of a newer forced air HVAC system for heating. Additionally, the property has a productive well and easy access to the Laplata Archuleta water line, providing flexibility for your water needs. "Cutie By The Creek" is ready to welcome you home to a blend of rural charm and modern conveniences.

39550 E Hwy 160, Bayfield

$200,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 804428 MLS

Escape to the mountains in this adorable little lake cabin! This 1 bedroom, 1 bath home has everything you need for the perfect vacation getaway. Enjoy the gorgeous lake views from your patio, or hop in the hot tub and let your stress melt away. There's also a handmade tree swing that is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the views. Property also includes a nice 10x16 shed to store all your toys and other essentials. Direct access to the lake provided by a short walk down a trail, or explore the area around Vallecito Reservoir on the numerous trails located nearby. Easy access to the marina and restaurants just a short drive down the road. There is room to park an RV or bring your toys! The possibilities are endless when you make this sweet little cabin your own.

14418 County Rd 501, Bayfield

$455,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 808359 MLS

Picture yourself and your family living in this newly remodeled classic Victorian residence that captures the essence of timeless Victorian elegance built in 1905 by the Founding Father of Bayfield Colorado , W.A. Bay. It is Nestled in the heart of downtown Bayfield, two blocks from Mill Street and numerous restaurants, shopping and the local micro-brewery. This home exudes character and charm from the second you step inside. As you enter the front door, you'll be greeted by original hardwood floors, crown molding, high ceilings, chandeliers with timeless intricate details and the craftsmanship that Victorian homes are known for. The large windows create a sense of openness with natural light throughout. You'll also find a bonus room for an office, playroom or workout area off the living room. The large dining room boasts a beautiful bay window, with easy access to a fully equipped eat in kitchen. A chef's dream featuring a gas stove, custom counters, and plenty of storage. One of the four bedrooms is located on the main floor. The main downstairs bathroom has lovely custom lavatory and a classic clawfoot tub, with in floor heating. As you move to the upstairs on a charming spiral staircase, you will find three bedrooms, and a sunny sitting room. The upstairs bathroom has a stand up shower. The second story has outside access to the backyard and a large deck. The outdoor area is a treat in itself with a beautiful lawn, sitting on a large corner lot. There is a newly installed sprinkler system that feeds the orchard of mature fruit trees and beautiful flowering plants. You will find a variety of plants including; rose, lilacs, echinacea, butterfly bushes, trumpet vines, lavender, tulips, daffodils, and numerous other perennials. There is a plethora of fruit from the several varieties of apple, chokecherry, sour cherry, mulberry, apricot and cherry trees. There are two outbuilding, one of which is a garage/storage shed and a cute SheShed/ManCave with ceiling fans, large windows, furniture and TV.

350 Pearl St, Bayfield

$310,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 800675 MLS

** SELLER MAY OFFER FINANCING WITH 20% DOWN** Charming 1930’s Gem with Generous Lot, Mature Fruit Trees, and Ample Storage. Looking for the perfect home in the charming town of Bayfield, Colorado? Look no further! This adorable gem boasts an oversized .64 acre lot complete with its own irrigation water, a large backyard full of mature fruit trees, a partially enclosed shop, a sizable barn, a garage with an attached storage shed, and an additional carport, giving you all the space you need to make your dream home a reality. With a single-car garage with a separate root cellar including wall-to-wall shelving, along with its own adjacent carport and storage area, you'll never have to worry about storage again! Unlock endless potential with this charming 1930's era home - customize to your heart's desire or simply make a few simple cosmetic upgrades and instantly fall in love with its timeless beauty. Inside you'll find a beautiful light-filled locking mudroom/entryway, a spacious living area with two wood burning stoves, a bright kitchen with a dining nook, a separate adjacent dining area, a main floor master with its own newly carpeted sunroom, an upstairs bedroom, and a large attached greenhouse with ample southern exposure helping keep the home warm in the winter. Enjoy the best of both worlds with this home; located just minutes from downtown restaurants, shops, schools, and the grocery store, yet with all the enjoyment and freedom of country living. Don't miss out on this opportunity to come by and see this charming find and all of the truly unique features it has to offer!

1791 Bayfield Pkwy, Bayfield

$560,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 811913 MLS

Don't miss out on this hard to find Vallecito Creek home. This rare waterfront residence is situated on .4 acres encompassing 105 feet of Vallecito Creek frontage AND NO HOA! While it has never be used for short term rental income, it could! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath house is ready to be transformed into your riverfront dream home. The versatile floor plan, stunning views, ample storage, office, and two garages offer an opportunity to make it your own. As you enter the home you are greeted by a warm family room with large windows overlooking Vallecito Creek. The large kitchen has a double oven, Bosch dishwasher, garbage disposal, trash compactor and custom cabinets with an abundance of pantry and work space. The dining area has a massive stone fireplace with an insert for high efficiency. Sit on the large, 16' X 27' trex-built deck and let the sounds of Vallecito Creek draw you in to your new mountain lifestyle. The craft room could easily become an art studio or sun room for plants and flowers. Outside there are 2 storage sheds providing space for tools and toys and a fenced area for your pets. The electric supply is backed up by a Kohler Generator that runs on propane, and automatically starts if there is a power outage. The Vallecito Reservoir is over 3.5 miles long and offers great opportunities for fishing, boating, paddle boarding and a host of other water activities. Bordering the Weminuche area of the San Juan National Forest, any outdoor enthusiast will find something to love. The property is a short distance to the 19.5 mile Vallecito Trail, taking you directly into the 499,771 acre Weminuche Wilderness.

2044 County Road 500, Bayfield

$1,229,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 821351 MLS

This is Colorado living at its finest. A luxury home, barn and other horse setup, private pond, and more sit on nearly 40 acres in Wallace Gulch. As you enter the home, you'll notice the southwestern influences perfectly matched with modern amenities. The dining room draws your eye as you enter as natural light streams in the large windows which also offer expansive views. French doors give access to the back patio and spacious yard. A couple steps down, the living room features a stunning gas fireplace with rock surround that warms the space complete with wood floors, a bay window, and plenty of room for all. Through another, smaller dining nook also warmed by a wood stove, the kitchen is a chef's dream. Alder wood cabinets blend exquisitely with the tile floors and accent the black granite countertops. A large butcher block island is ideal for the extra counter space and bar seating. Stainless steel appliances, farmhouse style sink, ample cabinets, and wet bar area make this area a wonderful gathering space. Double doors lead to a quaint patio area for outdoor dining while a sliding barn door leads to a pantry doubling as a laundry room for extra storage. A bedroom, office/craft room, and 1.25 baths are conveniently located on the main floor. Upstairs, the primary suite boasts three closets; a large bathroom with skylights, dual vanity, soaking tub, and shower; gas stove; floor to ceiling bay window; and a private balcony featuring amazing views. Additionally upstairs there is another large bedroom, a great bunk room that has a sizable bonus room attached extending the living space further. Outside, the horse barn has 3 large stalls - currently set up for two, a tack room, and an attached corral. The property is fenced and cross fenced providing an ideal grazing room. The southwest corner of the property adjoins nearly 1700 acres of BLM land ready for you to explore. The home is only 10 minutes away from Bayfield, conveniences are not hard to come by. Vallecito Reservoir is a mere 25 minutes to the north and Durango is 35 minutes for added shopping, restaurants, and more. Don't miss out on this Colorado horse property with unique touches and great views. The septic tank was replaced in February 2025.

4979 County Road 502, Bayfield

$1,550,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 808398 MLS

WELCOME TO THE YELLOW JACKET RANCH! Your beautiful country home awaits you! Fabulous views, 91+ acres, 3 natural spring fed ponds, 2 (two) car garages, one attached, one detached, and most importantly for you equestrian folks this property has access to National Forest on 3 sides. This property has everything you wanted and more! The main home is approximately 3800 sf in a 2-story with basement. 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath. Each bedroom has it’s own bathroom and walk-in closet, yes you read that right, it’s own private attached bathroom and walk-in closet. The main floor of the home has 2 large master bedrooms with 2 separate furnaces for each. As you enter the front door you are greeted with a very large and spacious family room with a beautiful gas fire place and gorgeous tongue and groove vaulted ceilings with skylights that let in beautiful natural light to the area. 1 master has beautiful views where you can see Elk, Bear, Turkey, and other wildlife. It has a beautiful walk in shower and a large walk in closet. The second master has it’s own bathroom with a garden jet tub as well as a sauna and a walk in closet. The sauna is also plumbed for a shower in the event someone would rather have a shower instead. The second floor has two bedrooms and a work station where you can view the beautiful vaulted ceilings and downstairs area. The basement has a spacious laundry room, office and bonus room. Room for lots of fun with family and friends. There is a large deck on the back of home to sit and entertain, cook out and enjoy the hot tub while taking in all of the amazing scenery! The property has a 6 stall barn in the pasture as well as a barn near the home with 2 additional stalls. Behind the barn is a small outdoor arena. The home comes with a water softener system with UV Purifying light that kills bacteria in the water. The well has been checked and produces 15 gallons per minute. Water has been adjudicated. This property also includes an additional 3 bedroom 2 bath home on the property with 3 outbuildings, 2 stalls, Loafing shed and Tack Room that has its own separate driveway. This home also has it’s own well and engineered septic as well. This property has tons of possibilities and all of the barns, fencing and arena will be just what you need to be able to run this ranching property. NO HOA or Covenants. Currently has Ag status. There really is too much to list here. If you are looking to enjoy the Colorado Ranch Lifestyle, then you do not want to miss this opportunity, it’s exactly what you are looking for.

28644 W Us 160th Hwy, Bayfield

$152,500

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 807906 MLS

Looking for an investment in La Plata County? This property is calling your name! This 2 Bedroom 1 Bath manufactured home, which has been purged to the land sits on .9 acres in downtown Bayfield on Mill Street. Located just a short distance from shopping and restaurants this makes for a perfect residence. The opportunities are endless when looking at this property, whether you want to fix up the current residence, or tear down for a new construction, you won't to miss this opportunity to buy in a prime Bayfield location.

16 E Mill St, Bayfield

$638,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 809154 MLS

Come on this journey through this beautiful mountain Cabin in South West Colorado. With some of the best views, access to the Pine River, and adventure at your fingertips. Many people want a cabin home, but only some will have one like this. I believe this is a dream Colorado cabin that will allow you and your families and friends to make memories to last a lifetime. Three reasons why this cabin could be for you. 1. The Views and Lifestyle 2. The Layout of the home 3. Access to adventure The views are stunning from the deck. You can hear the river, bringing this sense of peace and rest. The views over the top of the pines, looking over Vallecito Lake at the mountains and the Weminuchee wilderness, the biggest wilderness in Colorado. The home is four bed, three bath, 2500 Sq ft, on 1.9 acres with a big deck on the front and back. The master is on the main, and if you wanted, you could have a true mother-in-law suite above the garage. It is an open concept for the kitchen, two wood-burning fireplaces in the game room, and a living space. This is the perfect getaway to get to your cabin in the Mountains of Colorado. You have access to all the trails, hiking, biking, lake fishing, boating, river fishing, and hunting. People come from all over the country to spend their summers here. Winter activities ice fishing and the best Nordic skiing trail in the area. Make sure to check out our video of this home. We had a lot of fun shooting it; it is probably one of my favorite shoots we have done. Cheers

232 Wapiti Dr, Bayfield

$250,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 815693 MLS

In-Town Bayfield Property with Potential. Welcome to a delightful opportunity in the heart of the Town of Bayfield. This residence presents a perfect blend of comfort and potential, ideal for owner-occupant or savvy investors alike. Featuring 2 bedrooms and 1 bath, alongside an additional flex space, this home offers versatile living arrangements to suit various needs. Whether you envision a cozy retreat for yourself or seek to maximize rental income, the layout caters to your creative vision. Located within the Town of Bayfield, this property offers proximity to Highway 160 for the Durango commuter. Arrange a viewing today and discover how this Bayfield property can become the canvas for your ideal living or investment dream.

55 W North St, Bayfield

$375,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 806105 MLS

This cute cabin is conveniently located off the county road and sits on a total of 2.39 acres, which consists of four lots. You will love the open concept of the main level. The main focal point is the brick fireplace. One bedroom, the bonus room and bathroom round out this level. The upper half level is where you will find the second bedroom. Sit out on the large deck, which just had the deck floor replaced, and listen to and watch the wildlife that passes through the property. One of the lots still has the original outhouse. Bring your talents to turn this cute cabin into your own gem!

18159 County Road 501, Bayfield

$570,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 806465 MLS

A stunning, modern farmhouse home in Bayfield offering privacy on 3.369 acres. Recently updated there are new light fixtures, kitchen appliances, and solid alderwood doors. Hardwood floors lead you through the single level home to the four large bedrooms and two baths, one with a dual vanity. One of the bedrooms has direct access to the backyard. With high ceilings and a wood fireplace, the living room is cozy but spacious with high ceilings and large windows featuring incredible views. There’s a formal dining room that connects with the beautiful kitchen complete with quartz countertops, new appliances and custom built island. The yard is grassy and fenced with mature trees and expansive views. Outbuildings include a three car covered carport, shed, and greenhouse for storage, work space, horses and farm animals, and fresh produce. With short commute to Durango, Pagosa Springs, Vallecito Reservoir, and more area amenities, this is the perfect Colorado home.

16 County Road 526, Bayfield

$500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 822482 MLS

Welcome to your own slice of mountain paradise at Vallecito Lake! Tucked among the tall pines and set along the gentle flow of D Creek, this classic A-frame cabin offers a peaceful escape with an irresistible mix of rustic character and modern comforts. Lovingly maintained by the same family since 1980, this creekside retreat is ready for its next chapter. MAIN LEVEL: Step inside to a warm and inviting main level featuring a cozy living room anchored by a stone fireplace—perfect for gathering on cool mountain evenings. The bright dining area, just off the kitchen, is ideal for family meals, game nights, or crafting with a view. A spacious primary suite with en suite bath, a second full bathroom with laundry, and generous storage round out the main level. UPSTAIRS, you’ll find three large bedrooms, another full bath, and a sunny balcony overlooking the picturesque setting—perfect for morning coffee or evening stargazing. OUTSIDE, enjoy approximately 150 feet of water frontage on D Creek, where the soothing sound of water sets the tone for relaxation. With irrigation rights for up to 5,000 sq ft of lawn or garden space, there’s room to grow your mountain oasis. The expansive deck has been recently rebuilt, providing an ideal space for BBQs, morning yoga, or simply taking in the fresh pine-scented air. A storage shed keeps your gear organized, and with no HOA or covenants, and the home sold fully furnished, this is a turn-key opportunity for a vacation home or short-term rental. OUTDOOR OPPORTUNITIES: Just minutes from Vallecito Lake, you’ll enjoy easy access to a wide range of year-round recreation: boating, paddleboarding, and fishing in the summer, and snowshoeing and cross-country skiing in winter. The surrounding San Juan National Forest offers miles of hiking, biking, ATV, and horseback riding trails. Grab a meal at one of the nearby seasonal restaurants or explore the charming nearby communities of Bayfield and Durango. Don’t miss your chance to own this creekside gem in one of Southwest Colorado’s most treasured lake communities. The mountains are calling—make this your basecamp for adventure and relaxation!

1439 County Road 500, Bayfield

$575,000

813792 MLS

The Lake House is located in beautiful Vallecito. This 1 acre lake view property is in a prime location at the north end of the Vallecito Lake community. This mixed-use building has an amazing history in the area. Currently it has two rented residences, a rented office, a conference room, and meeting space. The Lake House hosts weddings, family reunions, fundraisers, meetings and local artisans. The current use and potential for additional income streams is virtually unlimited. Make this mixed-use building your dream! This property is part of the beautiful Vallecito Lake community. The reservoir is over 3.5 miles long and offers great opportunities for fishing, boating, paddle boarding and a host of other water activities. Bordering the Weminuche area of the San Juan National Forest, any outdoor enthusiast will find something to love. This building is a short distance to the 19.5 mile Vallecito Trail, taking you directly into the 499,771 acre Weminuche Wilderness.

17460 County Road 501, Bayfield

$15,500,000

9 Beds ⋅ 825344 MLS

A River Runs Through It! Cool Water Ranch is a truly beautiful mountain property with over 2 miles of the spectacular Pine River winding through it. The ranch is 1,015+- acres and will check all the boxes. In addition to excellent trout fishing, it also boasts great elk, mule deer, turkey and bear hunting. Cool Water Ranch has 5 vacation cabins and 14 RV spaces, all tucked on the west end, leaving the rest of the ranch wild and untouched. Cool Water Ranch can rightfully be described as the crown jewel of the Pine River Valley. The Ranch has a rich family history dating back to the early 1900's. This Ranch checks all the boxes and you would be hard pressed to find a more spectacular stretch of river, not to mention the beautiful mountain views. The Pine River meanders through over 2 miles through Cool Water Ranch on it's way down the valley and is known to have some of the best tailwater Rainbow Trout fishing in southwest Colorado. The Ranch is 1,015+- acres and consists of a couple of miles of river bottom and the Ranch extends up the mountainside to the north and the south sides of the Pine River Valley, bordering public lands on 4.5 miles of its boundary, allowing for seemingly limitless recreation and hunting opportunities. The Ranch is located just over a mile downstream from the Vallecito Lake Dam, which offers even more recreational opportunities, including fishing, motorized boating and swimming. There is approximately 20-30 acres of irrigable land in the valley floor, that was at one time in hay production, but is now used for livestock and big game grazing. The Ranch has 40% rights to the Ferrel Ditch and 100% rights to the Browner Canyon Ditch. Cool Water Ranch has a 1,155 SF farmhouse that has been the primary residence of the Seller since 1935 and has been updated through the years. There is also a hobby shop cabin, 5 short term rental cabins on the river and 14 RV rental spaces. The property is fenced and cross fenced and about 20-30 acres of the river bottom are irrigable. If two beautiful miles of the Pine River isn't enough, the property also boasts excellent mule deer, elk, turkey and black bear hunting. The Ranch is located in GMU's 75 & 751 and bull elk tags are available over the counter for the 2nd and 3rd rifle seasons, and available by drawing for the remaining seasons. Black Bear and Turkey tags are available over the counter as well. The Ranch qualifies for two applications in the land owner preference program for Mule Deer Buck vouchers. The Ranch borders tens of thousands of acres of public land, greatly expanding your hunting, hiking and horseback riding range. There are miles of 2-trac trails on the Ranch, providing you with not only good access to the Ranch but also giving you even more recreational opportunities for ATV's, horseback riding and hiking.

10643 County Road 501, Bayfield

$910,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 827456 MLS

Mountain View Equestrian Retreat – 38.79 Acres of Irrigated Beauty with a conservation easement that protects the land's agricultural heritage, wildlife and natural beauty. Breathe in the fresh mountain air and embrace the wide-open spaces on this 38.79-acre irrigated horse property, where country charm and thoughtful amenities create a one-of-a-kind retreat. The 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-level home offers 2,558 sq. ft. of inviting living space, complete with a dedicated office and finished basement—perfect for working from home or hosting guests. Step outside to a fully fenced yard and unwind on the large covered back deck, where expansive mountain views create the perfect backdrop for morning coffee or sunset gatherings. For those with horses or livestock, the property is a dream. Designed for livestock and farming, this property offers two horse stalls and a large tack room in the barn and approximately 29 acres of lush, irrigated grass hay ground that ensures a dependable resource for feed and income. The large, 60'x40' metal pole barn provides abundant storage for hay, and equipment. The land’s layout makes it ideal for riding, grazing, or simply enjoying the tranquility of rural life. Whether you’re envisioning trail rides through the crisp autumn air, producing your own hay, or hosting friends for a weekend in the country, this property offers the space, resources, and setting to bring that vision to life. It’s more than a home—it’s a lifestyle rooted in the beauty and bounty of Southwest Colorado. Schedule your showing today!

7351 County Road 523, Bayfield

Browse All Bayfield CO Historical Properties for Sale

Bayfield Historical Real Estate